Ethically Speaking - Was Paris Hilton Treated Fairly

Over the past few weeks we have seen Parisconsequences of driving while intoxicated. Paris
Hilton's drama being played out very publicly.Hilton made a choice to drive while intoxicated
Violating probation by driving on a suspendedback in September. She knew the consequences
license by no means would be so public for mostcould land her in jail. Ignorance can not be used as
of us. Rather, it is her celebrity status thata defense!!! She then chose to drive on a
brought it to the forefront of the news.suspended license and she chose to not enroll in a
Paris fought being incarcerated, then seemed tocourt ordered alcohol educational program. She,
accept that reality. She turned herself in andthen, effectively chose the consequence of
entered jail peacefully. She was able to sustainincarceration. Every choice we make has a
incarceration for three days. During those threeconsequence and surely Paris knew that this
days she lived segregated in a 12' by 8' cell with aoutcome was a possibility. This may not feel
bed, a sink and a toilet. She was allowed outsidegood, but it appears fair. It sounds as if most of
for one hour a day and then some time watchingus could expect the same should be follow in her
TV. This a far cry from the mansions thisfootsteps.
celebrity was accustomed to living.In life, we all face choices every day. Those
After three days, Paris was released from prisonchoices range from simple ones such as what
to house confinement because of a non-specifiedclothes to wear that day to complicated ones
medical condition that incarceration worsened.such as choices in the direction their corporation is
Apparently it was the recommendation of hergoing. With every choice, there is a consequence.
doctor for this to happen. The sheriff, based onUnethical choices lead to negative consequences.
medical information, released Paris to serve herParis made an unethical choice and she received
time confined within the walls of one of herher negative consequence. She compounded her
mansions.initial unethical choice by choosing to violate the
As you can imagine, there was public outcry.negative consequences. Thus, she received a
"Paris Hilton gets special treatment because she ismore stringent negative consequence. Had she
a celebrity!" There were demonstrations andchosen to respect the consequences of her initial
angry letters sent to the judge. How dare she bebehavior, this drama she is enduring would be
given "special treatment"!!! Many were ready tonon-existent and she would be experiencing
hang her, hang the sheriff and hang the judge!positive results. It appears that Paris Hilton
The perception was that she was a celebrity andcreated her outcome. Had she followed the law to
this "release" was unfair. After all would any of usbegin with, all this "suffering" would be a non-issue.
in a similar situation get the same treatment?Having said that, I also believe there is the
Amidst Paris' crying, her outcries, the judgeconcept of mercy. If she indeed has a medical
sentenced her back to prison to complete hercondition that jail worsens, then perhaps an
45-day confinement. The judge refused to hearalternative incarceration is called for such as would
any testimony regarding the alleged medicalbe true for a mere commoner such as myself. If
condition of Paris, and none was submitted to theit is a psychiatric condition, send her to a
court. He appeared unsympathetic to her pleaspsychiatric hospital. From what I understand, it is
and the pleas of her attorney. He was concernedno picnic there either. However, having to do
that public trust in the court was violated byincarceration in a mansion is hardly punishment.
those actions. Paris was lead away crying andHaving been to Federal Prison, I understand the
screaming. The paparazzi surrounded her anddespair at being locked up in a cell. Those first
there was no privacy.few days are the worse. It is the initial separation
So, here is the $64,000 question just as Paris isfrom family, it is the final ripping away of the
facing release - was Paris treated fairly? Mostillusions of success. You are only left with who
people felt that she was getting special treatmentyou are and if you don't know who you are, then
because she was a wealthy celebrity. Others felt,it is very frightening. I can truly identify with the
because they were her fans, that they didn'tsense of isolation and despondency Paris has gone
want her in prison because, after all, she was theirthrough. I was not a celebrity, but I had been a
idol - Paris Hilton. They felt she was being treatedvery successful partner in a CPA firm. I had all
unfairly. There is a third view. If Paris Hilton hadthe illusions of success. I had made it, I thought.
been Mary Smith, anonymous, would she haveHowever, I made an unethical choice of stealing
been released to do home incarceration?money from my clients which lead to my
According to Sheriff Baca (the sheriff in Paris'negative consequences. I did it all by myself. I
case), she would have. It is because of herdidn't intend to be incarcerated. I didn't intend to
celebrity status, that she is not having the sameharm my family, but I did both. Yes, those first
consideration as a "commoner".few days were the worst as I finally faced the
Let's step aside from the emotions and take thereality of myself.
role of an observer. An observer is not tied toPrison was an experience I would never want to
any outcome. It is only the observation of therepeat. However, I grew as a person and as a
event. Paris Hilton was arrested on September 8man as a result of that experience. I would not
in California for allegedly driving while intoxicated.be where I am today without the experience,
She was sentenced to 36 months of probation,unfortunately. If Paris chooses, she could learn
alcohol education, and fines. Her license wasabout her self, her values, and choices. She may
suspended. Paris failed to enroll in an alcoholcome out on the other side knowing more about
program and drove on a suspended license andherself and what is truly important and what is
was pulled over two times and lied each time.not. Moreover, she may use the experience to
There is much publicity about driving whilehelp others understand clearly the effects that
intoxicated. We all hear the horror stories and seechoices have.
the results. We all know the possible legal